Y

Open-source alternatives to YNAB

Actual Budget is the free, open-source YNAB alternative: the same envelope method, where every dollar you have gets a job, and it can import your YNAB budget with its history. YNAB is a yearly or monthly subscription; Actual has no subscription, works offline and keeps your budget on your own server.

7 alternatives Free apps Our pick: Actual Budget

At a glance

App Good for Code Import from YNAB Ease of use
Actual Budget Households and freelancers who want a YNAB-style budget without a subscription Code Open source Import from YNAB Yes Easy
Firefly III People who want to track every account, expense and bill in detail, with rules and reports Code Open source Import from YNAB Partly Easy
OpenBudgeteer Individuals and households who want a simple YNAB-style budget and are happy to import bank files Code Open source Import from YNAB No Easy
WYGIWYH People with money in several currencies who want a clear monthly picture without budgeting Code Open source Import from YNAB Partly Easy
Budget Board Households who want a Mint-style view of accounts, spending, budgets and goals on their own server Code Open source Import from YNAB Partly Some setup
Paisa People who want a private, long-term record of their spending and investments Code Open source Import from YNAB No Some setup
Sure People and families who want one private view of every account, their net worth, spending and budgets Code Open source Import from YNAB Partly Some setup

Why look for an alternative to YNAB?

YNAB, short for You Need A Budget, is a budgeting app built on envelope budgeting: you give every dollar you have a job before you spend it. It connects to banks in North America to bring in transactions.

People look for an alternative because YNAB is a subscription. When we checked its pricing page in November 2026, it cost $14.99 a month or $109 a year. Some also want their financial data on their own server rather than a company's. Actual Budget uses the same envelope method, imports your YNAB budget and has no subscription; you run it on your own server and bring your own bank sync if you want one. Sure suits people who want their net worth and investments alongside a simpler budget, Firefly III people who would rather track every account in detail than budget with envelopes, Paisa people who want their whole financial record, investments included, in plain text, and OpenBudgeteer people who want a simple bucket budget fed by bank files.

The alternatives, compared

Actual Budget

Our pick

A free envelope budget app, like YNAB, on your own server.

The closest match: the same envelope method, where you budget only the money you have and unspent money rolls over. It imports your YNAB budget with its history, works offline, has flexible rules and goal templates and custom reports. YNAB handles credit cards with existing debt more smoothly and has bank sync built in; in Actual, bank sync needs an account with a separate provider.

What you gain
  • No subscription; the app is free and you pay only for your server
  • Your budget is stored on your own server, with optional end-to-end encryption
  • It keeps working offline and syncs when you're back online
What is different
  • Bank sync isn't built in; it needs an account with a separate provider, which may charge a fee
  • There is an iPhone app in beta but no official Android app; on phones you install the web app
  • Credit cards that already carry debt take a little more setup than in YNAB
Easy Open source

Track every account, budget and bill in one private money manager.

Not envelope budgeting: you set a monthly amount for each budget and track every account in detail with double-entry bookkeeping, rules, bills, savings goals and many reports. Choose it if you want a full record of your money rather than YNAB's give-every-dollar-a-job method. It has no YNAB importer and no built-in bank sync.

What you gain
  • No subscription and no paid edition; you pay only for your server
  • Your financial records stay on your own server and are not sent anywhere unless you set that up
  • Detailed tracking of every account, with rules, bills, savings goals and reports
What is different
  • It is not envelope (zero-based) budgeting like YNAB; Actual Budget is closer to that
  • Bank sync is not built in; it needs Firefly III's separate Data Importer and a bank-connection provider, which this template does not include
  • There is no official phone app; it works in a browser, and some free apps by other people connect to it
Easy Open source

A free bucket budget app, like YNAB, on your own server.

Uses the same envelope idea with buckets: you put income into buckets for each purpose, and unspent or overspent amounts carry into the next month. It is much smaller than Actual Budget, with no YNAB importer, no bank sync, no phone app and one shared login, and you import bank statements as CSV files.

What you gain
  • No subscription; the app is free and you pay only for your server
  • Your budget stays on your own server, and no bank login is ever shared
  • Bucket types that spread yearly bills and savings goals over the months for you
What is different
  • There is no bank sync; you import CSV files from your bank or type transactions in
  • There is no importer for a YNAB budget, so you set up your buckets again
  • It's web only, with no phone or desktop app, though the pages fit small screens
Easy Open source

A self-hosted, multi-currency money tracker that skips budgeting.

Not a budgeting app, on purpose: you record income and spending across accounts and currencies and see what you have left each month, with savings kept apart. It suits people leaving YNAB because they no longer want to budget. It has no YNAB importer, so budgets don't carry over; transactions come in through a CSV import profile.

Easy Open source

A self-hosted Mint alternative for budgets, spending and goals.

Monthly category budgets with optional rollover of unspent money, rather than YNAB's give-every-dollar-a-job method, with goals, recurring transactions, trends and net worth across all your accounts. It has no YNAB importer, so only your transactions come across, as a CSV file, and bank sync needs a paid service such as SimpleFIN Bridge.

Some setup Open source

Personal finance manager for spending and investments.

Has monthly budgets per category with what is left to spend and rollover, but budgeting is one part of a wider record of spending, investments, bills and goals kept in a plain-text journal. Budgets are set in the journal text rather than YNAB's screens, it has no YNAB importer and no bank sync, and the double-entry format takes some learning.

Some setup Open source

Personal finance: net worth, spending and budgets.

Category budgets rather than YNAB's envelope method, inside a wider view of every account, your investments and your net worth. It imports YNAB's register CSV exports, from the current YNAB and YNAB 4, so your transactions come across, but you set up your budget amounts again.

Some setup Open source

Moving from YNAB

Export your budget from YNAB as a JSON file, then bring it in with Actual's YNAB importer when you open or create a budget. Accounts, categories, payees and transactions come across with your history. Check your credit card accounts after the import, since Actual handles card debt a little differently, and set up your rules again. If you want transactions to arrive on their own, connect a bank sync provider for your region, such as SimpleFIN Bridge in North America; otherwise import bank files. Firefly III has no YNAB importer: export your transactions from YNAB as a CSV file and bring them in with Firefly III's separate Data Importer app, which this template does not include, then set up your budgets again. Sure imports YNAB's register CSV export with your transactions; then set a budget for each category. Paisa has no YNAB importer: export your transactions from YNAB as a CSV file, bring them in with a Paisa import template you set up for its columns, then write your monthly budgets in the journal. Budget Board takes the same CSV export through its CSV import, where you match the columns; then set a monthly budget for each category. OpenBudgeteer has no YNAB importer: add your bank accounts with their current balances, set up a bucket for each YNAB category, then import new transactions from your bank's CSV files. WYGIWYH takes YNAB's CSV export through an import profile you write for its columns; your budgets stay behind, since WYGIWYH does not budget.

Questions

What is the best open-source alternative to YNAB?

Start with Actual Budget. All 7 are free and open source.

Is there an alternative for people who want to stop budgeting?

Yes, WYGIWYH. It is deliberately not a budgeting app: you track income and spending across accounts and currencies and see what is left each month, while savings stay untouched.

Should I choose Actual Budget, Sure, Firefly III, Paisa, Budget Board or OpenBudgeteer?

Choose Actual Budget if you budget the YNAB way, giving every dollar a job; it uses the same envelope method and imports your YNAB budget. Choose Sure if you want every account, your investments and your net worth in one view, with simpler category budgets. Choose Firefly III if you want detailed tracking of every account with double-entry bookkeeping and reports, rather than envelopes. Choose Paisa if you want budgets, spending and investments in a plain-text journal you own. Choose Budget Board for simple monthly category budgets and savings goals in a Mint-style overview. Choose OpenBudgeteer if you want a simple bucket budget and are happy to import bank CSV files.

Can Actual Budget import from YNAB?

Yes. Actual has a built-in importer for YNAB's current version and for the older YNAB 4, and it keeps your transaction history.

Does Actual Budget connect to my bank?

Only through a separate provider you sign up with, such as SimpleFIN Bridge in North America, which has its own small fee. Without one, you import bank files such as CSV, OFX or QFX, or type transactions in.

Is there an Actual Budget phone app?

The web app works on a phone and can be added to your home screen. An iOS app is in beta, and there is no official Android app.

Are these YNAB alternatives really free?

Yes, Actual Budget, Firefly III, OpenBudgeteer, WYGIWYH, Budget Board, Paisa and Sure are free. To run them you need Cloudgate and a server. Use hosted Cloudgate, which can also provide the server, or install Cloudgate on a server of your own for free. Cloudgate's plans and prices are at cloudgate.octabyte.io/pricing. One server can run several apps.

Do I need a developer to replace YNAB?

No. Cloudgate installs the app you choose on your server and gives it a secure web address, and you use it in your browser instead of YNAB.