Firefly III vs YNAB
Firefly III and YNAB do different jobs: Firefly III is a free, open-source finance manager that records every account in detail on your own server, while YNAB is a paid envelope budgeting app at $14.99 a month or $109 a year. Firefly III suits people who want a full, private record of their money in any currency. YNAB suits people who want to give every dollar a job, with bank connections and phone apps ready to use.
Firefly III vs YNAB at a glance
| What is compared | | Y YNAB |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Firefly III Free, with no paid edition; you pay for the server | YNAB $14.99 a month or $109 a year (USD), after a 34-day free trial |
| Hosting | Firefly III On your own server only | YNAB YNAB's cloud only |
| Source code | Firefly III Open source, AGPL-3.0 | YNAB Proprietary |
| Budget method | Firefly III Detailed tracking with double-entry bookkeeping, plus a monthly amount for each budget | YNAB Envelope budgeting: assign every dollar you have to a category before you spend it |
| Bank sync | Firefly III Through the separate Data Importer and a provider such as Enable Banking or SimpleFIN | YNAB Built in for select US, Canadian, UK and EU banks; file import elsewhere |
| Currencies | Firefly III Any currency, mixed across accounts | YNAB One currency per plan; you cannot mix currencies in one plan |
| Mobile apps | Firefly III No official app; use it in a phone's browser, or a free app by others such as Waterfly III | YNAB Apps for iPhone, Android and Apple Watch, plus the web |
| Import from YNAB | Firefly III No direct importer; bring transactions in as CSV through the Data Importer | YNAB Not needed |
How Firefly III and YNAB differ
Firefly III and YNAB pricing
As of November 2026, YNAB has one set of features and two ways to pay, in US dollars:
- Monthly: $14.99 a month.
- Yearly: $109 a year, which YNAB shows as $9.08 a month.
There is a 34-day free trial with no card needed when you sign up with YNAB directly, college students get a free year, and one subscription can be shared with up to five other people.
Firefly III has no licence fee and no paid edition. You pay for a small server and, if you want bank sync, for any provider that charges for it. Enable Banking, for example, has a free restricted mode for your own linked accounts.
Budgeting method: detailed tracking or envelopes
This is the difference that decides most choices. YNAB is envelope budgeting: you assign the money you have now to categories, and spending comes out of them. If a category runs short, you move money from another.
Firefly III is a detailed record of your money. Every transaction is booked at both ends with double-entry bookkeeping, across checking, savings, credit cards, loans and mortgages. You set a monthly amount for each budget and see what is left to spend, sort spending into categories and tags, list your bills and save towards goals with piggy banks. It takes longer to learn than YNAB.
Bank sync and imports
YNAB connects to banks for you. Its pricing page lists bank import for select US, Canadian, UK and EU banks, with file import elsewhere.
Firefly III has no bank connection of its own. Its separate Data Importer reads CSV, CAMT.052 and CAMT.053 files, and connects to banks through providers such as Enable Banking, which covers banks in 29 European countries, and SimpleFIN. You run the Data Importer next to Firefly III.
Currencies, apps and privacy
Firefly III handles any currency, and accounts in different currencies sit side by side. YNAB uses one currency per plan and cannot mix currencies within it.
YNAB has apps for iPhone, Android and Apple Watch, plus the web. Firefly III has no official phone app; it works in a phone's browser, and free apps by other people, such as Waterfly III for Android, connect to it through its API.
Your YNAB data lives in YNAB's cloud. Firefly III keeps your records on your own server and does not contact outside servers unless you set that up, and it supports two-step sign-in.
Should you choose Firefly III or YNAB?
Choose Firefly III if
- You want no subscription: Firefly III is free, and you pay only for the server.
- You want a full record of every account, loan and mortgage, with double-entry bookkeeping.
- You live with more than one currency, for example a home account in euros and savings in pounds.
- You want your financial records on your own server, with no outside connection unless you set one up.
- You like rules, recurring transactions, piggy banks and detailed reports, and a REST API for your own tools.
Choose YNAB if
- You want envelope budgeting, where every dollar gets a job; Firefly III does not work that way.
- You want bank connections built in, without running a second app or signing up with a provider.
- You want official phone apps: YNAB has them for iPhone, Android and Apple Watch, and Firefly III has none.
- You want something quick to learn, with a human support team and a managed service.
- You share a budget with family: one YNAB subscription covers up to six people.
Moving from YNAB to Firefly III
Firefly III has no YNAB importer, so your YNAB budget does not come across as it is. Export your plan and transactions from YNAB's web app as CSV files, then bring the transactions in with Firefly III's separate Data Importer, where you match each column to a Firefly III field; the Data Importer is not part of this template. Create your accounts first, with their opening balances, so transfers land in the right place. YNAB's categories can become Firefly III categories, but your monthly budget amounts, targets and category notes have to be set up again, and YNAB's envelope balances have no direct match in Firefly III.
Questions
Is Firefly III better than YNAB?
Firefly III is better than YNAB for detailed, private tracking of every account and currency, free on your own server. YNAB is better for envelope budgeting, where you give every dollar a job, and for built-in bank connections and phone apps.
Is Firefly III free?
Yes. Firefly III is free and open source under the AGPL-3.0 licence, with no paid edition, while YNAB costs $14.99 a month or $109 a year. To run Firefly III you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
Can I import my YNAB data into Firefly III?
Partly. Firefly III has no YNAB importer, but you can export your transactions from YNAB as a CSV file and bring them in with Firefly III's separate Data Importer. Your YNAB budget amounts and targets have to be set up again in Firefly III.
Does Firefly III use envelope budgeting like YNAB?
No. YNAB uses envelope budgeting, where you assign every dollar you have before you spend it. Firefly III records every transaction with double-entry bookkeeping and lets you set a monthly amount for each budget, so it is closer to a detailed money tracker; Actual Budget is the self-hosted app closest to YNAB's method.
Does Firefly III connect to my bank like YNAB?
Not on its own. Firefly III connects to banks through its separate Data Importer and a provider such as Enable Banking in Europe or SimpleFIN, and the Data Importer also reads CSV and CAMT files. YNAB includes bank connections for select US, Canadian, UK and EU banks in its subscription.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check YNAB’s own pricing page before you decide.