Storyden vs Circle
Storyden or Circle depends on whether you sell access: Storyden is a free, open-source forum with a wiki-style knowledge base on your own server, while Circle is a hosted platform from $89 a month, billed yearly, with courses, events, live streams and payments. Storyden suits clubs and hobby groups that discuss and collect what they know. Circle suits creators and businesses that charge for membership, courses or events.
Storyden vs Circle at a glance
| What is compared | | C Circle |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Storyden Free and open source, with no paid edition or member limit; you pay for the server | Circle Professional $89, Business $199, Scale $419 a month, billed yearly; Circle Plus by quote |
| Transaction fees | Storyden None | Circle 2% on Professional, 1% on Business and Scale, 0.5% on Circle Plus |
| Hosting | Storyden Your own server | Circle Circle's cloud only |
| Source code | Storyden Open source, MPL-2.0 | Circle Proprietary |
| Discussions | Storyden Threads in categories, with replies, quotes, tags and reactions | Circle Discussion spaces, alongside courses, events and live streams |
| Knowledge base | Storyden A library of wiki-style pages with fields, and edits that moderators approve | Circle Courses; a knowledge engine on the Scale plan |
| Courses, events and payments | Storyden Not built in | Circle Built in on every plan |
| Phone apps | Storyden No app; a layout made for phone browsers | Circle iPhone, Android and desktop apps; branded apps on Circle Plus |
How Storyden and Circle differ
Storyden and Circle pricing
As of November 2026, Circle's plans, in US dollars a month, billed yearly and before tax:
- Professional: $89, with a 2% transaction fee, 3 admins and 10 moderators.
- Business: $199, with a 1% fee, adding workflows, APIs and white-labelling.
- Scale: $419, with a 1% fee, adding AI agents, a knowledge engine and custom single sign-on.
- Circle Plus: priced by Circle's sales team, with a 0.5% fee and branded phone apps.
Every plan allows unlimited members, and Professional, Business and Scale have a 14-day free trial.
Storyden has no licence fee, no paid edition and no fee on payments. Your cost is the server, and a small one is enough: its docs say it idles at about 80 MB of memory. Its optional AI tools use your own OpenAI or Anthropic account, which that provider bills you for.
A forum with a knowledge base
Storyden puts discussion and shared knowledge side by side. Members start threads in categories, reply, quote, tag and react. Next to the forum is a library: a tree of wiki-style pages with fields such as Status or Author, shown side by side in a table. Members can suggest new pages or edits, and moderators accept them before they go live. Shared links are saved and searchable, and threads and pages can be gathered into collections.
Circle is built around selling access. Next to discussion spaces it has courses, live events and streams, payments and a custom domain on every plan, with AI tools on top.
Members, moderation and sign-in
Storyden has Admin, Member and Guest roles, or roles you create, each with its own permissions and badge. Moderators handle reports, give private warnings, keep staff notes, suspend accounts and block words. Members sign in with a password, a passkey, or a Google, GitHub or Discord account.
Circle gives 3 to 10 admins and 10 to 100 moderators depending on the plan, and adds AI moderation on Scale.
Phone apps and maturity
Circle has iPhone, Android and desktop apps on every plan. Storyden has no phone app; it works in any browser with a layout made for small screens.
Storyden is a young project that is still changing, so check the release notes before each update. Circle is a managed service, with onboarding and priority support on its higher plans.
Should you choose Storyden or Circle?
Choose Storyden if
- You want a community with no monthly plan and no fee on payments.
- Your members build shared knowledge, such as guides, reading lists or directories, and you want it next to the forum.
- You want members to suggest pages and edits that a moderator approves before they go live.
- You want your members and posts on your own server and domain, on a small server.
- You want sign-in with a password, a passkey, or a Google, GitHub or Discord account.
Choose Circle if
- You sell courses, memberships or event tickets: Circle has payments, courses and live events built in, and Storyden has none of these.
- You want native phone apps, or apps under your own brand on Circle Plus.
- You want live streams and rooms inside the community.
- You want mature software with a vendor's onboarding and support; Storyden is a young project that still changes.
- You want member chat, which Storyden does not have.
Moving from Circle to Storyden
Storyden has no Circle importer, so plan to start fresh. Circle admins can export members as a CSV file from Audience, and can ask Circle support for a full export of members, spaces, posts and comments as CSV files, without uploaded media. In Storyden, register your own account right after setup, because the first account becomes the admin. Create a category for each Circle space, move your guides and resources into Library pages, and add your email server if you want email sign-in. Then share the address with your members. Old posts do not move on their own, so keep the Circle community readable for a while. Courses, events and paid memberships need separate tools.
Questions
Is Storyden better than Circle?
Storyden is better than Circle for a free forum with a shared knowledge base on your own domain, with no fee on payments. Circle is better if you sell courses, memberships or events, or want native phone apps and member chat, which Storyden does not have.
Is Storyden free?
Yes. Storyden is free and open source under the MPL-2.0 licence, with no paid edition or member limit, while Circle starts at $89 a month billed yearly. To run Storyden you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
How much does Circle cost compared with Storyden?
As of November 2026, Circle costs $89 a month for Professional, $199 for Business and $419 for Scale, billed yearly, plus a 2% to 0.5% fee on payments. Storyden has no licence fee; you pay only for the server, and its docs say 1 GB of memory is plenty for a small to medium community.
Can I import my Circle community into Storyden?
Not directly. Storyden has no tool to import a community from Circle, so most communities start fresh in Storyden. Circle can export members, spaces, posts and comments as CSV files, which you can keep as an archive.
What is the Storyden library?
The Storyden library is a tree of wiki-style pages next to the forum, for guides, reading lists or directories. Pages can have fields such as Status, and members can suggest pages or edits for a moderator to approve before they go live.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check Circle’s own pricing page before you decide.