Helfertool vs SignUpGenius
Helfertool or SignUpGenius comes down to the kind of sign-up you run: Helfertool is free, open-source shift planning for event volunteers on your own server, with no ads and no limits, while SignUpGenius is a hosted service for every kind of sign-up sheet, free with paid plans that remove ads. Helfertool suits festivals, clubs and nonprofits that staff an event with shifts. SignUpGenius suits schools, churches and groups running potlucks, classroom slots and payments.
Helfertool vs SignUpGenius at a glance
| What is compared | | S SignUpGenius |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Helfertool Free, with no ads and no limit on events, shifts or helpers; you pay only for the server | SignUpGenius Free plan; Silver $8.99, Gold $22.49 and Platinum $44.99 a month billed yearly; Enterprise by quote |
| Hosting | Helfertool On your own server | SignUpGenius SignUpGenius's hosted service |
| Source code | Helfertool Open source, AGPL-3.0 | SignUpGenius Proprietary |
| Ads | Helfertool None | SignUpGenius Ad-free on 1 sign-up with Silver, 10 with Gold, all with Platinum |
| Kinds of sign-up | Helfertool Event jobs and timed shifts with a set number of helpers | SignUpGenius Many formats: volunteer slots, potlucks, school events, conferences and more |
| Volunteer accounts | Helfertool None needed: helpers fill in a short form and confirm by email | SignUpGenius Not needed to sign up for a slot |
| Event extras | Helfertool Private shifts, coordinators per job, badges, T-shirt and gift tracking, equipment lending | SignUpGenius Reminder emails, payment collection, text messages on paid plans, waitlists on Gold |
| Languages and apps | Helfertool English and German, in any browser; no phone app | SignUpGenius In any browser, with nothing to install; SignUpGenius says it has no app by design |
How Helfertool and SignUpGenius differ
Helfertool and SignUpGenius pricing
As of November 2026, SignUpGenius has five plans:
- Free: unlimited sign-up pages in many formats, confirmation and reminder emails, group tools, payment collection and email support.
- Silver: $8.99 a month billed yearly ($107.89 a year) or $11.99 monthly. One ad-free sign-up, 2 custom questions, 150 text invites or updates and 2,500 emails a month.
- Gold: $22.49 a month billed yearly ($269.89 a year) or $29.99 monthly. Ten ad-free sign-ups, 10 administrators, 500 texts and 10,000 emails a month, tabbed sign-ups and waitlists.
- Platinum: $44.99 a month billed yearly ($539.89 a year) or $59.99 monthly. Unlimited ad-free sign-ups, 20 administrators, 1,500 texts and 20,000 emails a month, custom URLs and phone support.
- Enterprise: custom pricing.
Payments collected through SignUpGenius carry their own processing fees.
Helfertool has no fee, no ads and no plan. Your cost is a small server, which Cloudgate sets up with its database, and an email sending service for confirmations.
Shifts at events, or every kind of sign-up
Helfertool does one job: staffing an event. You create jobs such as bar, entrance or set-up, and each job gets shifts with a start, an end and the number of helpers it needs. The overview shows at a glance which shifts are still short, and statistics cover filled and empty slots, T-shirt sizes and food preferences.
SignUpGenius covers far more ground. It handles volunteer slots, but also potlucks, parties, school events and conferences, with sign-ups duplicated for recurring events, calendar sync and payment collection.
Running the event
Helfertool adds tools that event organisers use on the day. You can hide internal jobs and send a private link, give each team lead access to their own job's helpers, print badges for access control, note who got their T-shirt or thank-you gift, and lend out equipment with barcodes. Lists export to Excel or PDF, and you can email the helpers of one job or the whole event.
SignUpGenius focuses on reaching people: automatic confirmation and reminder emails on every plan, text messages on paid plans, custom questions and more administrators as you move up.
Ads, data and hosting
SignUpGenius is a hosted service. Its paid plans are priced partly on how many of your sign-ups are free of ads.
Helfertool runs on your own server, so there are no ads, and your volunteers' names, emails and phone numbers stay with you. The trade-off is that you look after the server and connect an email service. Helfertool is made by volunteers in Germany and works in English and German.
Should you choose Helfertool or SignUpGenius?
Choose Helfertool if
- You run an event with shifts, such as a festival, and want to see at once where you are short of helpers.
- You want no ads for your volunteers and no plan limits as the event grows.
- You want volunteers' names, emails and phone numbers on your own server.
- You want badges, T-shirt and gift tracking and equipment lending in the same tool.
- You want team leads to manage the helpers of their own job.
Choose SignUpGenius if
- You run many kinds of sign-up, such as potlucks, classroom slots or parent-teacher conferences, not only event shifts.
- You want to collect payments or sell tickets through the sign-up.
- You want text-message invites and updates, which SignUpGenius includes on paid plans.
- You want a hosted service with support, instead of running a server and an email service.
- You need a sign-up in a language other than English or German.
Moving from SignUpGenius to Helfertool
There is no SignUpGenius importer, so set up your next event in Helfertool rather than moving old sheets. Download your current sign-up lists from SignUpGenius to keep them. In Helfertool, add your email server so helpers get confirmations, create the event, then a job for each area, such as bar, entrance or set-up, with its shifts and the number of helpers each needs. Share the event's sign-up link where you posted the SignUpGenius one, and send private links for internal shifts. Payments, text messages and non-shift sign-ups do not carry over. Next year, duplicate the event to start from the same jobs and shifts.
Questions
Is Helfertool better than SignUpGenius?
Helfertool is better than SignUpGenius for staffing an event with volunteer shifts, with no ads, no limits, badges and coordinators per job. SignUpGenius is better for general sign-up sheets such as potlucks or classroom slots, for collecting payments, and for a hosted service you don't have to run.
Is Helfertool free?
Yes. Helfertool is free and open source under the AGPL-3.0 licence, with no ads and no paid plan, while SignUpGenius charges to remove ads. To run Helfertool you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide, plus an email sending service for confirmations.
How much does SignUpGenius cost compared with Helfertool?
As of November 2026, SignUpGenius has a free plan, and its paid plans cost $8.99 (Silver), $22.49 (Gold) and $44.99 (Platinum) a month billed yearly, or $11.99, $29.99 and $59.99 billed monthly. Helfertool has no fee; you pay only for the server and an email service.
Can I import my SignUpGenius sign-ups into Helfertool?
No. Helfertool has no SignUpGenius importer, so you download your lists from SignUpGenius to keep them and set up your next event's jobs and shifts in Helfertool.
Do volunteers need an account for Helfertool or SignUpGenius?
No. In Helfertool, volunteers pick their shifts on the event's page, fill in a short form and confirm by email. SignUpGenius also lets people sign up for a slot without creating an account.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check SignUpGenius’s own pricing page before you decide.