ChurchCRM vs Planning Center
ChurchCRM or Planning Center comes down to cost and scope: ChurchCRM is free, open-source church management software on your own server, while Planning Center is a set of cloud apps, each with a free tier and monthly plans that grow with a church. ChurchCRM suits a church that wants members, groups, check-in, volunteers and giving records with no subscription. Planning Center suits a church that also wants worship planning, online giving and phone apps for members and staff.
ChurchCRM vs Planning Center at a glance
| What is compared | | P Planning Center |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ChurchCRM Free, with no paid edition and no fee per member; you pay only for the server | Planning Center People is free; Services, Check-Ins, Giving, Groups and others are free at small sizes, then $15 to $239 a month each |
| Hosting | ChurchCRM On your own server | Planning Center Planning Center's cloud service |
| Source code | ChurchCRM Open source, MIT licence | Planning Center Proprietary |
| Worship planning | ChurchCRM None; no song lists or service run sheets | Planning Center Services: service plans, song library, rehearsal tools and volunteer scheduling |
| Giving | ChurchCRM Records gifts on deposit slips and pledges by fund, with year-end statements; no online giving | Planning Center Online giving, from 2.15% + $0.30 per card gift in the US, plus Text2Give |
| Check-in | ChurchCRM A check-in kiosk in a tablet's browser, with walk-in guest sign-up | Planning Center Check-Ins, with its own iPhone and Android app and a Headcounts app |
| Mobile apps | ChurchCRM None; a member portal in the phone's browser | Planning Center Church Center for members, plus Planning Center, Services, Check-Ins, Music Stand and Headcounts apps |
| Import | ChurchCRM CSV import that matches each column to a ChurchCRM field | Planning Center CSV import into People, and a full CSV export of the database |
How ChurchCRM and Planning Center differ
ChurchCRM and Planning Center pricing
As of November 2026, Planning Center sells each product as its own monthly subscription, in US dollars, with no contract, setup fee or cancellation fee:
- People (the member database and reports): free, with no limit.
- Check-Ins: free for 10 check-ins on a Sunday, then $15 a month for 30, $32 for 75, $69 for 200, $115 for 500, $179 for 1,000 and $239 for unlimited.
- Services: free for 5 team members, then $15 a month for 20, $32 for 50, $69 for 150, up to $239 for unlimited.
- Groups: free for 15 group members, then $15 a month for 75, $32 for 200, $69 for 500, up to $239 for unlimited.
- Giving: free for 10 donations a month, then $15 for 75, up to $239 for unlimited, plus processing fees of 2.15% + $0.30 per card gift and $0.30 per bank transfer in the US.
- Registrations and Calendar room booking follow the same $15 to $239 steps. Texting costs $0.02 per message.
A church with 200 people at Sunday check-in, 75 people in groups and 50 on worship teams would pay $69 + $15 + $32, or $116 a month, before giving fees.
ChurchCRM has no licence fee and no paid edition. Your cost is the server. ChurchCRM needs PHP 8.4, MySQL 8.4 or MariaDB 10.11, and at least 256 MB of memory for PHP, 512 MB or more recommended. On Cloudgate it runs on a small server.
Hosting and your members' data
Planning Center is a cloud service: your people, attendance and giving records are kept on its servers, and it looks after updates and backups.
ChurchCRM runs on a server you choose, so member, family and giving records stay with you. The trade-off is that you look after the server, its updates and backups. The code is public under the MIT licence.
What Planning Center has that ChurchCRM lacks
- Worship planning. Planning Center Services builds service plans with songs, people and notes, keeps a song library with keys and arrangements, imports from SongSelect and adds rehearsal tools. ChurchCRM has none of this.
- Online giving. Planning Center Giving takes card, bank and text gifts. ChurchCRM only records gifts the office enters.
- Phone apps. Planning Center has iPhone and Android apps: Church Center for members, and Planning Center, Services, Check-Ins, Music Stand and Headcounts for staff and volunteers.
- Workflows and forms. People has multi-step workflows and forms that add people to them.
- Integrations. Planning Center lists Mailchimp, SongSelect, Zapier, ProPresenter and others, and has a documented API.
What ChurchCRM covers
ChurchCRM keeps people and families with custom fields, groups and Sunday school classes, events with a check-in kiosk, volunteer scheduling, a member portal, and pledges, deposits and year-end giving statements. It can sync with Mailchimp and send email through a sending service you connect. It is translated into 49 locales. Every feature is in the free version, with nothing kept for a paid plan.
Should you choose ChurchCRM or Planning Center?
Choose ChurchCRM if
- You want no subscription: ChurchCRM costs nothing at any size, while Planning Center plans rise as your check-ins, groups and teams grow.
- You want member and giving records on your own server, under your control.
- Your church needs members and families, groups, Sunday school, check-in, volunteer scheduling and giving statements, and plans worship elsewhere.
- You want open code under the MIT licence that you can read and change.
Choose Planning Center if
- You plan worship services: Planning Center Services has service plans, a song library, SongSelect import and rehearsal tools, which ChurchCRM does not.
- You want to take gifts online, by card, bank transfer or text, through Planning Center Giving.
- Your members and volunteers want phone apps: Church Center, Services and Check-Ins are on iPhone and Android.
- You would rather not run a server, and want Planning Center's support team and ready-made integrations such as Mailchimp, SongSelect and Zapier.
- Your church is small enough that Planning Center's free tiers cover you.
Moving from Planning Center to ChurchCRM
Export your people from Planning Center People as a CSV file: open People, choose Actions, then Import & Export CSV, start the export and use the download link it emails you. In ChurchCRM, open the CSV import, match each column to a ChurchCRM field, and check that families came across together. Recreate your groups, Sunday school classes and events by hand, and turn on volunteer scheduling if you schedule teams. Past giving does not carry over through the people import, so start new deposits in ChurchCRM and keep Planning Center's giving reports for earlier years. Worship plans, song libraries and online giving have no place in ChurchCRM, so keep those in other tools.
Questions
Is ChurchCRM better than Planning Center?
ChurchCRM is better than Planning Center for a church that wants free member, attendance, volunteer and giving records on its own server with no subscription. Planning Center is better for a church that also needs worship planning, online giving and phone apps for members and staff.
Is ChurchCRM free?
Yes. ChurchCRM is free and open source under the MIT licence, with no paid edition and no fee per member, while Planning Center charges monthly for most products above their free tiers. To run ChurchCRM you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
How much does Planning Center cost compared with ChurchCRM?
As of November 2026, Planning Center People is free, and each other product has a free tier and monthly plans from $15 to $239 a month, set by size; Check-Ins is $69 a month for 200 check-ins on a Sunday, for example. ChurchCRM has no licence fee at any size; you pay only for the server.
Can I import my Planning Center data into ChurchCRM?
Partly. Planning Center People exports your whole database as a CSV file, and ChurchCRM's CSV import lets you match each column to a ChurchCRM field. Groups, events, giving history and worship plans do not come across this way.
Does ChurchCRM take online donations like Planning Center Giving?
No. ChurchCRM records gifts that the church office enters on deposit slips, tracks pledges by fund and prints year-end giving statements, but it does not process card or bank payments. Planning Center Giving takes gifts online for a processing fee.
Does ChurchCRM have a phone app like Church Center?
No. ChurchCRM has no app in the app stores; members use its portal in a phone's browser and a tablet can run the check-in kiosk. Planning Center offers the Church Center app for members and separate apps for Services and Check-Ins.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check Planning Center’s own pricing page before you decide.