Black Candy vs Spotify
Black Candy or Spotify comes down to whose music you play: Black Candy is a free, open-source server that streams the music files you own to a web player and its own free iPhone and Android apps, while Spotify is a paid service that rents you its catalogue monthly. Black Candy suits families who own their music and want simple official apps with no subscription. Spotify suits people who want almost any song on demand, with recommendations and podcasts.
Black Candy vs Spotify at a glance
| What is compared | | Spotify |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Black Candy Free, with no paid edition, and free phone apps; you pay only for the server and storage | Spotify Free with ads; Premium Individual $12.99 a month, Family $21.99 a month for up to 6 people |
| Hosting | Black Candy On your own server | Spotify Spotify's cloud only |
| Source code | Black Candy Open source, MIT, including the phone apps | Spotify Proprietary |
| Music | Black Candy Only the files you upload, such as MP3, FLAC, AAC and Ogg | Spotify Spotify's streaming catalogue, plus your local files in its apps |
| Phone apps | Black Candy Free official apps on the App Store, Google Play and F-Droid | Spotify Official apps for phones and computers; works with over 2,000 devices |
| Discovery | Black Candy Search, genre and year filters, favourites and recently played; no recommendations | Spotify DJ, daylist, Blend and playlists made for you |
| Accounts | Black Candy One for each person, added by the admin, at no extra cost | Spotify One per Individual plan; Duo for 2 and Family for up to 6 at one address |
| Other apps | Black Candy No Subsonic support, so third-party music apps can't connect | Spotify Spotify's own apps only |
How Black Candy and Spotify differ
Black Candy and Spotify pricing
As of November 2026, Spotify's US site shows these plans, each billed monthly:
- Free: Spotify's ad-supported service.
- Premium Individual: $12.99 a month, after a free month for new subscribers.
- Premium Duo: $18.99 a month for two people at the same address.
- Premium Family: $21.99 a month for up to six people at the same address.
- Premium Student: $6.99 a month for eligible students.
Premium removes ads, lets you download songs, play albums in any order and skip as often as you like, and streams at up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz.
Black Candy has no licence fee, no paid edition and no paid app. Your cost is the server and the storage your music needs; on Cloudgate it runs on a small server.
Your own music or Spotify's catalogue
Spotify streams its catalogue: you play almost anything, but you rent it, and you lose access when you stop paying. Spotify's apps can also play music files stored on your device.
Black Candy streams only the music you upload. You hear your own files, and nothing disappears when a licence ends. It sorts them into albums, artists, genres and years, and it can fetch artist and album pictures from Discogs with a free token. Files a browser can't play are converted as they stream, and lossless files can be shrunk to MP3 to save mobile data.
Black Candy and Spotify phone apps
This is where Black Candy is closest to Spotify. Both have their own official apps, so nobody has to choose an app made by someone else. Black Candy's apps are free and open source, on the App Store, Google Play and F-Droid, and its web player also works in a phone's browser.
Spotify reaches further: it says it works with over 2,000 devices, with one-tap switching between them, and Premium adds offline downloads.
Black Candy keeps to its own apps. It does not support Subsonic, so third-party music apps cannot connect.
Discovery and features
Spotify builds playlists for you: its DJ, daylist, Blend with friends, and Jam for listening together in real time.
Black Candy has no catalogue to recommend from. It offers search across artists, albums, songs and playlists, filters by genre or year, playlists, favourites, a play queue you can reorder, and a list of recently played albums for each person. It has no smart playlists, share links or Last.fm scrobbling.
Should you choose Black Candy or Spotify?
Choose Black Candy if
- You already own your music as files, such as ripped CDs or bought downloads, and want to stop paying a subscription.
- You want official phone apps from the same project as the server, free on iPhone and Android.
- You want a simple server with one web player rather than a choice of outside apps.
- You want an account for each person in the household, with their own playlists and favourites, at no extra cost.
- You want an open-source licence (MIT) for the server and the apps.
Choose Spotify if
- You want to play almost any song without buying or ripping it first.
- You want recommendations of new music, such as Spotify's DJ, daylist and playlists made for you.
- You want offline downloads, lossless streaming and over 2,000 compatible devices in one service.
- You want podcasts, video shows and audiobooks in the same app.
- You don't want to look after a server, upload files and press Sync when you add music.
Moving from Spotify to Black Candy
Black Candy has no Spotify importer and no playlist import, because Spotify rents you its songs rather than selling you files. Start with the music you own: on Cloudgate, upload it at Black Candy's second, File Browser address in folders such as Artist/Album, then press Sync in Black Candy's Settings, or turn on the Media Listener so new files are added by themselves. If you kept local files in Spotify's desktop app, upload those too. Rebuild your Spotify playlists by hand in Black Candy. Then install the free Black Candy app on each phone and sign in with your server's address, email and password. Spotify's recommendations, followed artists and podcasts do not carry over.
Questions
Is Black Candy better than Spotify?
Black Candy is better than Spotify if you own your music as files and want free official phone apps, an account for everyone and no subscription. Spotify is better if you want almost any song on demand, recommendations and podcasts, because Black Candy has no music catalogue and plays only what you upload.
Is Black Candy free?
Yes. Black Candy is free and open source under the MIT licence, and its iPhone and Android apps are free too, while Spotify Premium costs $12.99 a month for one person as of November 2026. To run Black Candy you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
How much does Spotify cost compared with Black Candy?
As of November 2026, Spotify's US prices are $12.99 a month for Premium Individual, $18.99 for Duo, $21.99 for Family (up to 6 accounts) and $6.99 for Student, with a free tier that has ads. Black Candy has no fee for any number of accounts; you pay only for the server and storage.
Can I import my Spotify playlists into Black Candy?
No. Black Candy has no playlist import and no Spotify importer, so you upload the music files you own and rebuild your Spotify playlists by hand in Black Candy.
Does Black Candy have a phone app like Spotify?
Yes. Like Spotify, Black Candy has its own official apps: free and open source, on the App Store for iPhone and on Google Play and F-Droid for Android. You sign in with your Black Candy server's address, email and password.
Can I use Subsonic apps with Black Candy instead of Spotify?
No. Black Candy does not support the Subsonic standard, so apps such as Symfonium or DSub cannot connect; you listen through Black Candy's web player or its own phone apps. If you want Subsonic apps, Navidrome is the better fit.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check Spotify’s own pricing page before you decide.