C

Open-source alternative to CommCare

DHIS2 is a free, open-source CommCare alternative for collecting health and programme data on phones and in the browser, offline, and rolling it up into dashboards, charts and maps from each site to the whole country. CommCare’s cloud plans run from $100 to over $4,000 a month, billed yearly; self-hosted DHIS2 has no subscription and no paid edition, though CommCare is stronger at phone-first case management and DHIS2 needs a large server.

Free app Code: Open source Import from CommCare: Partly Some setup

Why look for an alternative to CommCare?

CommCare, from Dimagi, is a mobile data collection and case management platform for frontline workers, used in health and development programmes. Most organisations buy Dimagi's hosted plans; its pricing page lists Standard at $100, Pro at $500, Advanced at $1,000 and Enterprise from $4,000 a month, billed yearly, with a free plan for testing.

Programmes look for an alternative because those plans are a recurring cost that rises with each tier, and many ministries and NGOs want their data on a server they control. A self-hosted DHIS2 collects routine data offline on phones and in the browser and turns it into dashboards and maps, with no subscription.

How DHIS2 compares

Health data, from clinic forms to dashboards and maps.

Collects routine data on Android phones with the free Capture app and in the browser, both offline, follows individual people through tracker programmes, and rolls the data up from each site to district and country in dashboards, charts, pivot tables and maps. CommCare is stronger at phone-first case management with its app builder; DHIS2 has no iPhone app, needs an 8 GB server, and a new install has to be designed, with your sites, data elements and forms, before anyone can use it.

What you gain
  • No licence or per-user fee, and no paid edition holding features back
  • Dashboards, charts and maps are built in, with no separate reporting tool
  • Figures roll up from each site to district and national level automatically
What is different
  • It needs real set-up work before staff can enter data, often with help from a trained implementer
  • The phone app is for Android only
  • It is a large app that needs a bigger server than most tools in this catalogue
Some setup Open source

Moving from CommCare

There is no importer for CommCare, so plan DHIS2 first: set up your organisation hierarchy of sites, your data elements, and the data sets or tracker programmes that replace each CommCare form. Export the data you need to keep from CommCare as CSV or Excel files and bring it into DHIS2 with its Import/Export app or the API, once it matches your new data elements. Install the DHIS2 Capture app on your workers' Android phones, give each worker an account, and keep CommCare running until the first reporting periods arrive in DHIS2.

Questions

What is the best open-source alternative to CommCare?

DHIS2 is the free, open-source alternative to CommCare for mobile data collection and case management in the catalogue today. Collects routine data on Android phones with the free Capture app and in the browser, both offline, follows individual people through tracker programmes, and rolls the data up from each site to district and country in dashboards, charts, pivot tables and maps. CommCare is stronger at phone-first case management with its app builder; DHIS2 has no iPhone app, needs an 8 GB server, and a new install has to be designed, with your sites, data elements and forms, before anyone can use it.

Does DHIS2 work offline on phones?

Yes, like CommCare. The free DHIS2 Capture app for Android works offline and syncs when the phone reconnects, and data entry in the browser also works offline. There is no iPhone app; DHIS2 also accepts data by SMS.

Should I choose DHIS2 or CommCare?

DHIS2 if you report routine data from many sites and need it rolled up into national dashboards and maps. CommCare if your main need is phone apps that guide frontline workers through visits and cases.

Can I import my CommCare data into DHIS2?

Partly. DHIS2 has no CommCare importer, but data exported from CommCare as CSV or Excel can go into DHIS2 through its Import/Export app or API, once it matches the data elements you set up. Plan your DHIS2 sites, data elements and forms first.

Is DHIS2 really free compared with CommCare?

Yes, DHIS2 is free. To run them you need Cloudgate and a server. Use hosted Cloudgate, which can also provide the server, or install Cloudgate on a server of your own for free. Cloudgate's plans and prices are at cloudgate.octabyte.io/pricing. One server can run several apps.

Do I need a developer to replace CommCare?

No. Cloudgate installs DHIS2 on your server and gives it a secure web address, and you use it in your browser instead of CommCare.