# PieFed vs Reddit

> PieFed or Reddit comes down to who runs the forum: PieFed is free, open-source software you run on your own server, with your own rules, no ads and private communities, while Reddit is one large site that Reddit runs and pays for with ads. PieFed suits a club or project that wants Reddit-style communities it controls. Reddit suits anyone who wants its huge audience and official apps, with nothing to host.

- Page: https://cgt.octabyte.io/compare/piefed-vs-reddit/
- PieFed: https://cgt.octabyte.io/templates/piefed/
- Reddit: https://www.reddit.com
- Facts checked: November 2026

## PieFed vs Reddit at a glance

| | PieFed | Reddit |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Price | Free, with no paid edition; you pay only for the server | Free to use and to start a community; Reddit Premium removes ads from $5.99 a month |
| Hosting | On your own server and domain | Reddit's own site only |
| Source code | Open source, AGPL-3.0 | Proprietary |
| Audience | Starts empty; members can join communities on Lemmy, Mbin and other PieFed servers | Reddit's whole user base can find and join your community |
| Private communities | Private, invite-only communities next to public ones, or a members-only site | Public, restricted, private and 18+ communities, set per community |
| Post types | Links, text, images, polls and events, with flairs and a wiki per community | Posts with links, text or images, with post and user flair |
| Mobile apps | Install the website from the browser, or use apps such as Interstellar, Voyager or Mlem | Official Reddit apps for iPhone and Android |
| Import from Reddit | None; you start fresh | Not needed |

## How PieFed and Reddit differ

### PieFed and Reddit pricing

Reddit is free to read, post on and start a community on, and it pays for itself with ads. As of November 2026, Reddit Premium, which removes ads, costs $5.99 a month or $49.99 a year (USD) on the web, and $6.99 a month or $59.99 a year when bought in the iPhone or Android app. Reddit says prices may vary by country.

PieFed has no licence fee, no paid edition and no fee per member. Your cost is the server. PieFed's developers suggest at least 2 CPU cores and 4 GB of memory, and say a small site can use much less with smaller settings, which is how Cloudgate sets it up on a medium server.

### Who runs the forum

On Reddit, your community is a subreddit inside Reddit's site. Reddit sets the sitewide rules, shows ads, runs the apps and decides who may use its data API.

On PieFed, you run the whole site. You choose the address, the rules, the moderators and who can sign up, and PieFed has no ads, no tracking and no algorithmic feed. The trade-off is that you look after the server, its updates and its backups.

### Audience and federation

Reddit's biggest advantage is its audience: people already browsing Reddit can find and join your community. A new PieFed server starts with only the members you invite.

PieFed makes up some of that through federation over ActivityPub. Your members can follow and comment in communities on Lemmy, Mbin and other PieFed servers, and people there can join yours. An admin can also subscribe the server to popular communities elsewhere so the front page isn't empty.

### Communities, privacy and moderation

Both have communities people subscribe to, up and down votes, sorts such as Hot, Top and New, threaded comments and flair.

- **Privacy.** Reddit lets each community be public, restricted, private or marked 18+. PieFed lets you mark a single community private and invite-only, and choose whether members, moderators or only the owner can invite people. The whole site can be members-only too.
- **Extras.** PieFed adds events with a time and place, a wiki page for each community, topics that group communities, feeds that bundle several communities, and private chat.
- **Moderation.** Reddit gives moderators a mod queue, AutoModerator rules that filter posts by keyword or domain, removal reasons and mod mail. PieFed has reports, a moderation log, bans and blocks for users, websites and whole servers, and filters members can set for words, bots and sites.

### Apps

Reddit has official apps for iPhone and Android. PieFed's website can be installed on a phone from the browser and works like an app, and apps made for Lemmy and PieFed, such as Interstellar, Voyager, Blorp and Summit, connect to it, with Mlem on iPhone.

## Should you choose PieFed or Reddit?

### Choose PieFed if

- You want the forum on your own domain, under your own rules, with no ads or tracking.
- You want some communities private and invite-only on an otherwise public site.
- You want polls, events and a wiki page inside each community.
- You want your posts and members' data on your own server, not a platform's.
- You want to link up with Lemmy and other fediverse servers instead of standing alone.

### Choose Reddit if

- You need an audience: on Reddit, people already browsing can find and join your community.
- You want polished official apps for iPhone and Android and nothing to host or update.
- You rely on AutoModerator rules, removal reasons and a mod queue that Reddit has built in.
- Your members already live on Reddit and won't make a new account elsewhere.

## Moving from Reddit to PieFed

There is no import from Reddit, so posts, comments, votes and members stay where they are. Pick your PieFed web address first, because it cannot change once people start posting. Sign in with the admin username and the password Cloudgate created, choose open, application or closed sign-ups, and add an email server so members can confirm their address and reset passwords. Create a community for each topic, mark any members-only ones as private, set up flairs and copy your subreddit's rules across. To fill the front page on day one, PieFed's admin pages can subscribe your server to existing communities on Lemmy and other PieFed servers. Then pin a post in your subreddit that points to the new forum, and keep the subreddit open for a while.

## Questions

### Is PieFed better than Reddit?

PieFed is better than Reddit for a group that wants its own Reddit-style forum, on its own domain and rules, with no ads and some communities kept private. Reddit is better for reaching a large audience, with official phone apps and built-in moderation tools such as AutoModerator, and nothing to host.

### Is PieFed free?

Yes. PieFed is free and open source under the AGPL-3.0 licence, with no paid edition, ads or fee per member. To run PieFed you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide. Reddit is also free to use, with an optional ad-free Reddit Premium subscription.

### Can I import my subreddit into PieFed?

No. PieFed has no importer for Reddit, so a subreddit's posts, comments and members stay on Reddit. Most groups start a fresh PieFed community and pin a link to it in the old subreddit.

### Can PieFed users talk to people on Reddit?

No. PieFed connects to Lemmy, Mbin and other fediverse servers over ActivityPub, but Reddit is a closed site that does not take part. PieFed members can join communities on those servers, not subreddits.

### What is the difference between PieFed and Lemmy as Reddit alternatives?

PieFed and Lemmy are both self-hosted, Reddit-style forums that connect to each other. PieFed adds private, invite-only communities, polls, events, community wikis and more moderation filters, while Lemmy has more dedicated phone apps.

## Sources

- [What is a Reddit Premium subscription?](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043034412-What-is-a-Reddit-Premium-subscription)
- [Reddit community types](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360060416112-What-are-public-restricted-private-and-premium-only-communities)
- [Reddit AutoModerator](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/15484574206484-Automoderator)
- [Reddit post flair](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/15484545678996-Post-Flair)
- [Official Reddit app FAQ for iOS](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/17098769739156-Official-Reddit-App-FAQ-for-iOS)
- [Join PieFed](https://join.piefed.social/)
- [PieFed source code](https://codeberg.org/rimu/pyfedi)
