Paymenter vs WHMCS
Paymenter or WHMCS comes down to licence cost against breadth: Paymenter is free and open source and imports your WHMCS data, while WHMCS is a paid monthly licence with many more gateways, registrars and add-ons. Paymenter suits web, VPS and game-server hosts that want to leave WHMCS without starting over. WHMCS suits hosts that sell domain names, rely on less common integrations or want a long-established product with commercial support.
Paymenter vs WHMCS at a glance
| What is compared | | W WHMCS |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Paymenter Free, with no paid edition of the software; you pay only for the server | WHMCS Self-hosted from $34.95 a month for 250 active clients; WHMCS Cloud from $9.99 a month for 25 |
| Hosting | Paymenter On your own server, or Paymenter's managed PaaS from $5 a month | WHMCS On your own server, or WHMCS Cloud, managed by WHMCS |
| Source code | Paymenter Open source, MIT | WHMCS Proprietary, encoded; needs the ionCube Loader to run |
| Payment gateways | Paymenter Stripe, PayPal and Mollie, more from its extension marketplace | WHMCS More than 70, including Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net and GoCardless |
| Server panels | Paymenter cPanel, Plesk, DirectAdmin, Enhance, Pterodactyl, Convoy, Virtualizor and VirtFusion | WHMCS cPanel, Plesk, DirectAdmin, CloudLinux, OnApp, SolusVM and more |
| Domains | Paymenter No registrar modules built in; selling domains needs an extension | WHMCS More than 100 domain registrars |
| Import from WHMCS | Paymenter Built-in importer for clients, products, services, invoices, payments and tickets | WHMCS Not needed |
How Paymenter and WHMCS differ
Paymenter and WHMCS pricing
As of November 2026, WHMCS sells two kinds of plan, all billed monthly before tax, with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Self-hosted WHMCS, on your own server:
- Plus: $34.95 a month for up to 250 active clients.
- Professional: $54.95 a month for up to 500 active clients.
- Business: $84.95 a month for up to 1,000 active clients, with larger tiers up to 10,000.
WHMCS Cloud, managed by WHMCS:
- Starter: $9.99 a month for up to 25 active clients, then $0.40 per extra client.
- Growth: $25 a month for up to 100, then $0.25 per extra client.
- Expansion: $75 a month for up to 300, then $0.25 per extra client.
An active client is anyone with at least one active product, service, add-on or domain. WHMCS says licence prices change on January 1, 2027.
Paymenter has no licence fee and no client limit, so your cost is the server. If you would rather not run one, Paymenter also offers a managed PaaS from $5 a month.
Moving your WHMCS data
This is where Paymenter stands out from other free billing tools. Its importer reads a copy of your WHMCS database and brings across clients, products, orders, services, invoices, payments and tickets, so you do not rebuild your client list by hand. It wipes Paymenter's existing data, so it is a one-time step on a fresh install.
Payments, servers and domains
Both sell plans, bill on a schedule, take payments, set up and suspend services, and run a support desk. The difference is in what each connects to:
- Payments. Paymenter lists Stripe, PayPal and Mollie, with more from its marketplace. WHMCS lists more than 70 gateways.
- Servers. Paymenter covers cPanel, Plesk, DirectAdmin and Enhance for web hosting, Pterodactyl for game servers, and Convoy, Virtualizor and VirtFusion for VPS. WHMCS covers cPanel, Plesk, DirectAdmin, CloudLinux, OnApp, SolusIO and SolusVM.
- Domains. WHMCS works with more than 100 registrars. Paymenter has no registrar modules built in.
Source code and support
WHMCS is closed source. Its files are encoded and need the ionCube Loader to run. It has commercial support, a large marketplace of add-ons, and paid extras such as project management and software licensing.
Paymenter is open source under the MIT licence. You can read and change its code and themes, and help comes from its community and GitHub. Self-hosting means you look after updates and backups.
Should you choose Paymenter or WHMCS?
Choose Paymenter if
- You want no licence fee at any number of clients, now or later.
- You want to leave WHMCS and bring your clients, services, invoices and tickets with you.
- You sell game servers or VPS: Paymenter has modules for Pterodactyl, Convoy, Virtualizor and VirtFusion.
- You want open-source code under the MIT licence, with themes and extensions you can change.
- Your client and payment records should stay on your own server.
Choose WHMCS if
- You sell domain names: WHMCS works with more than 100 registrars, and Paymenter has none built in.
- You need a gateway or panel that only WHMCS supports: it lists more than 70 gateways.
- You want a long-established product with commercial support and a large add-on marketplace.
- You want extras such as project management, software licensing or SSL reselling through MarketConnect.
Moving from WHMCS to Paymenter
Paymenter has a built-in WHMCS importer, run from the command line. Back up your WHMCS database, load it into a temporary database next to Paymenter, and run the import command. It brings currencies, clients, admins, product categories, products, tickets, orders, services, cancellations, invoices and payments. It deletes any data already in Paymenter, so run it on a fresh install before you set anything else up. Afterwards set up email sending, your payment gateways and your servers, and check each product is linked to the right server before the next billing run. Domain names, WHMCS add-ons and custom modules do not have a ready counterpart in Paymenter.
Questions
Is Paymenter better than WHMCS?
Paymenter is better than WHMCS for a web, VPS or game-server host that wants free, open-source billing and a direct import of its WHMCS data. WHMCS is better for a host that sells domain names or needs many gateways, panels and add-ons, with commercial support behind it.
Is Paymenter free?
Yes. Paymenter is free and open source under the MIT licence, with no paid edition of the software, while WHMCS is a paid monthly licence. To run Paymenter you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
Can I import my WHMCS data into Paymenter?
Yes. Paymenter's built-in importer copies clients, admins, products, orders, services, invoices, payments and tickets from a copy of your WHMCS database. It replaces any data already in Paymenter, so run it on a fresh install.
How much does WHMCS cost compared with Paymenter?
As of November 2026, self-hosted WHMCS costs $34.95 a month for up to 250 active clients, $54.95 for 500 and $84.95 for 1,000, and WHMCS Cloud starts at $9.99 a month for 25. Paymenter has no licence fee at any size; you pay only for the server.
Can Paymenter sell domain names like WHMCS?
Not out of the box. Paymenter includes no domain registrar modules, so selling or renewing domains depends on an extension, while WHMCS works with more than 100 registrars.
Is Paymenter good for game-server hosting?
Yes. Paymenter has modules for Pterodactyl game servers and for Convoy, Virtualizor and VirtFusion virtual servers, so a paid order creates the server and an unpaid invoice suspends it. WHMCS covers VPS through modules such as SolusVM and OnApp.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check WHMCS’s own pricing page before you decide.