Open Journal Systems vs Scholastica
Open Journal Systems (OJS) or Scholastica comes down to cost against convenience: OJS is free, open-source software that runs submissions, peer review and the journal website on your own server, while Scholastica is a hosted service that charges per submission, per journal and per typeset article. OJS suits journals willing to set up and run their own system. Scholastica suits journals that want a ready service with support and typesetting.
Open Journal Systems vs Scholastica at a glance
| What is compared | | S Scholastica |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Open Journal Systems Free and open source, with no fee per submission or journal; you pay for the server | Scholastica Peer review $10 per submission plus $500 a year; open access website $1,549 a year per journal |
| Hosting | Open Journal Systems On your own server, or paid hosting from the Public Knowledge Project (PKP) | Scholastica Scholastica's cloud |
| Source code | Open Journal Systems Open source, GPL-3.0 | Scholastica Proprietary |
| Peer review | Open Journal Systems Anonymous or open review, review rounds, reminders and editorial decisions | Scholastica Manuscript table, task assignment and reminders, file anonymization and email templates |
| Journal website | Open Journal Systems Included, with issues, themes and PDF, HTML and other formats | Scholastica Open access publishing platform, sold separately per journal |
| Typesetting | Open Journal Systems Not included | Scholastica Production service: $7 per 500 words, per figure or table and per block equation |
| Indexing and DOIs | Open Journal Systems Crossref or DataCite DOIs with your own membership, ORCID, Google Scholar, DOAJ and PubMed exports | Scholastica Crossref, DOAJ, PubMed Central and Portico, with XML and metadata sent automatically |
| Support | Open Journal Systems PKP's community forum and documentation, or PKP's paid support | Scholastica Training and user support included at no charge |
How Open Journal Systems and Scholastica differ
OJS and Scholastica pricing
As of November 2026, Scholastica sells three services, priced in dollars:
- Peer review system: $10 per submission and $500 a year. Journals with 500 or more submissions a year pay $8 per submission. Submissions are billed monthly, and the yearly fee once a year.
- Open access publishing platform: $1,549 a year per journal, or $1,239 per journal for publishers with 10 or more journals.
- Production service (typesetting): $7 per 500 words, $7 per figure or table and $7 per block equation, billed monthly.
Scholastica lists no setup fees and no long-term contract. A journal can also have authors pay the submission fee.
Open Journal Systems has no licence fee and no paid edition. Your cost is the server: on Cloudgate, OJS runs on a small server. DOIs need your journal's own Crossref or DataCite membership, which applies whichever system you use.
Peer review and editorial work
Both cover the path from submission to decision. In OJS, authors submit through a step-by-step form, editors invite reviewers, choose anonymous or open review, set due dates and let the journal send reminders. Each manuscript moves from review to copyediting and production on one dashboard, with statistics such as acceptance rates and days to a first decision.
Scholastica's peer review system has a manuscript table, task assignment and reminders, file versions and anonymization, email templates and analytics, and optional Similarity Check and RightsLink connections.
The journal website and hosting
OJS includes the published journal: volumes and issues on a website that works on phones, with themes and PDF, HTML and other formats. One installation can host many journals in one or many languages.
Scholastica's website is a separate product, its open access publishing platform, priced per journal. It includes hosting and design, a website editor, a PDF viewer, readership analytics and archiving.
Typesetting and indexing
Scholastica sells typesetting: layout, reference checking and proofing, with formatted PDFs and JATS XML. It also sends metadata to Crossref, DOAJ, PubMed Central and Portico.
OJS has no typesetting service; you upload finished files. It registers DOIs with Crossref or DataCite, links ORCID iDs and exports article details for Google Scholar, DOAJ and PubMed.
Setup and support
Scholastica includes training and user support for everyone at no charge. With OJS, you set up the journal yourself, including its sections, review forms and emails, and add an email server so authors and reviewers are notified. Help comes from PKP's documentation and community forum, and PKP sells hosting, support and training for those who want it.
Should you choose Open Journal Systems or Scholastica?
Choose Open Journal Systems if
- You want no fee per submission or per journal, however many manuscripts you receive.
- You run several journals: one OJS installation holds many, each with its own editors, look and address.
- You want manuscripts, reviews and reader data on your own server.
- You publish in several languages: OJS can run a journal in one language or many.
- You want open-source software with a long-standing academic community and the option to export your data.
Choose Scholastica if
- You want to start quickly, with no server to install or update.
- You want typesetting done for you: Scholastica's production service makes PDFs and JATS XML.
- You want training and support included in the price.
- You want Scholastica to send metadata to Crossref, DOAJ, PubMed Central and Portico for you.
- You prefer no long-term contract and paying as you go: Scholastica says you can cancel at any time.
Moving from Scholastica to Open Journal Systems
There is no Scholastica importer in OJS. Set up your journal in OJS first: sections, review forms, email templates and theme, plus an email sending service so authors and reviewers get notified. Take new submissions in OJS from a set date and let manuscripts already in review finish in Scholastica. Add back issues with OJS's QuickSubmit tool, or with its Native XML import if you can convert your records, and update your DOIs to point to the new article pages. PKP, which makes OJS, also sells a paid migration service.
Questions
Is OJS better than Scholastica?
Open Journal Systems (OJS) is better than Scholastica for a journal that wants no fee per submission and is willing to set up and run its own system. Scholastica is better for a journal that wants a hosted service with included support and a paid typesetting service.
Is Open Journal Systems free?
Yes. Open Journal Systems (OJS) is free and open source under the GPL-3.0 licence, with every feature in one download, while Scholastica charges per submission and per journal. To run OJS you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide.
How much does Scholastica cost compared with OJS?
As of November 2026, Scholastica's peer review system costs $10 per submission plus $500 a year, its open access platform $1,549 a year per journal, and typesetting $7 per 500 words, figure, table or block equation. Open Journal Systems has no licence fee or submission fee.
Can I move my journal from Scholastica to OJS?
Partly. Open Journal Systems has no Scholastica importer, so new submissions start in OJS while open ones finish in Scholastica. Back issues go into OJS through its QuickSubmit tool or Native XML import, and PKP sells a paid migration service.
Does OJS do typesetting like Scholastica?
No. Open Journal Systems publishes the files you upload, such as PDF and HTML, but has no typesetting service. Scholastica sells typesetting per article, with formatted PDFs and JATS XML.
Can OJS run more than one journal?
Yes. One Open Journal Systems installation can host many journals, each with its own editors, settings and web address, at no extra cost. Scholastica's open access platform is priced per journal.
Sources
Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check Scholastica’s own pricing page before you decide.