Open Archiver vs MailStore

Open Archiver or MailStore comes down to cost and compliance: Open Archiver's free edition is open source, runs on Linux and has no per-mailbox fee, while MailStore Server is paid Windows software that includes retention policies, legal hold and journaling. Open Archiver suits small teams that need one searchable copy of every company email. MailStore Server suits businesses that must prove retention and want an Outlook add-in and vendor support.

Open Archiver: Free, open source Open Archiver: Some setup Facts checked

Open Archiver vs MailStore at a glance

What is compared Open Archiver M MailStore
Price Open Archiver Free edition with no per-mailbox fee; Enterprise Edition from €14 to €65 per mailbox, one-time MailStore Starter kit from $259 plus VAT for up to 5 users, with 12 months of update and support
Hosting Open Archiver On your own Linux server, used in a web browser MailStore On your own Windows 11 or Windows Server 2016 to 2025 machine
Source code Open Archiver Open source, AGPL-3.0 MailStore Proprietary
Mail sources Open Archiver Google Workspace, Microsoft 365 and IMAP; PST, EML and Mbox import MailStore Microsoft 365, Exchange, Google Workspace, IMAP and POP3; PST and EML files
Compliance Open Archiver Retention policies, legal hold, audit trail and journaling only in the paid Enterprise Edition MailStore Retention policies, legal hold, journaling, auditing and an Auditor user type included
Search and access Open Archiver Full-text search of mail and attachments in the browser, with roles and two-step sign-in MailStore Full-text search, an Outlook add-in and Web Access for browsers, phones and tablets
Integrity and storage Open Archiver A fingerprint for each email and file; local disk or S3-compatible storage, duplicates stored once MailStore Hash values and AES-256 encryption; de-duplication and compression
Import from MailStore Open Archiver No direct importer; bring MailStore exports in as PST or EML files MailStore Not needed

How Open Archiver and MailStore differ

Open Archiver and MailStore pricing

As of November 2026, MailStore Server's starter kit costs from $259 plus VAT for up to five users, and includes 12 months of Standard Update and Support. Standard and Premium support can be bought for one, two or three years; MailStore shows no prices for more users or for support, and quotes them on request. A free 30-day trial is available.

Open Archiver's free edition has no licence fee and no seat limit. Your cost is the server: at least 4 GB of memory, and disk that grows with your archive. Its Enterprise Edition is a one-time payment per archived mailbox, from €65 a seat for one to four mailboxes down to €14 a seat for 500 or more, with one year of updates and support. Admin and search-only users are not counted.

Hosting: a Linux server or a Windows machine

MailStore Server runs on Windows 11 or Windows Server 2016 to 2025, and supports up to 2,000 users. Open Archiver runs on a Linux server, and keeps the archive on the server's disk or in S3-compatible storage. Both keep your mail on hardware you control.

Archiving and search in Open Archiver and MailStore

Both copy every mailbox into one archive and keep adding new mail, so mail stays findable after it is deleted or someone leaves. Open Archiver connects to Google Workspace, Microsoft 365 and IMAP, and imports PST, EML and Mbox files. MailStore also archives Microsoft Exchange and POP3 mailboxes.

Open Archiver searches the text of emails and attachments, with filters for sender, recipient, mailbox and date, and shows the thread each email belongs to. MailStore offers full-text search in Web Access and in an Outlook add-in, and can restore or export emails in standard formats.

Compliance: retention, legal hold and journaling

This is the main difference. MailStore Server includes retention policies, legal hold, journaling, event auditing and an Auditor user type for outside auditors. In Open Archiver, retention policies, legal hold, an audit trail, journaling, four-eyes deletion and encryption at rest come only with the paid Enterprise Edition. The free edition gives each email and attachment a fingerprint, so you can check that nothing was changed.

Should you choose Open Archiver or MailStore?

Choose Open Archiver if

  • You want email archiving with no per-mailbox fee: Open Archiver's free edition has no seat limit.
  • You would rather run a Linux server than keep a Windows machine for the archive.
  • You mainly need one searchable copy of all company mail, including the text inside attachments.
  • You want the archive on your own server, stored as standard .eml files, with open-source code (AGPL-3.0) you can read.

Choose MailStore if

  • You must meet retention rules: MailStore Server includes retention policies, legal hold and journaling, which Open Archiver keeps for its paid edition.
  • Your staff work in Outlook and want the archive there through MailStore's Outlook add-in.
  • You run Microsoft Exchange on your own servers, which MailStore lists as a source.
  • You want a mature product with vendor support, including phone support on the Premium plan.

Moving from MailStore to Open Archiver

Open Archiver cannot read a MailStore archive, so connect the live mailboxes first. For Google Workspace, a super admin creates a service account with domain-wide delegation; for Microsoft 365, an admin registers an app in Microsoft Entra with mail read permissions. Add the source in Open Archiver and it finds every user, copies their existing mail and keeps archiving new mail. Mail that now exists only in MailStore can come across as files: export it from MailStore as EML or PST and import those into Open Archiver. Retention rules, legal holds and audit history do not carry over. Keep MailStore running until you have checked that the mail you must keep is searchable in Open Archiver.

Questions

Is Open Archiver better than MailStore?

Open Archiver is better than MailStore for small teams that want a free, open-source archive of Google Workspace, Microsoft 365 or IMAP mail on a Linux server. MailStore Server is better for businesses that need retention policies, legal hold and journaling included, an Outlook add-in and vendor support.

Is Open Archiver free?

Yes. Open Archiver's free edition is open source under the AGPL-3.0 licence, with no per-mailbox fee, while MailStore Server is paid per user. To run Open Archiver you need Cloudgate and a server, which hosted Cloudgate can provide; its paid Enterprise Edition adds the compliance features.

How much does MailStore cost compared with Open Archiver?

As of November 2026, MailStore Server starts at $259 plus VAT for up to five users, with 12 months of Standard Update and Support; larger licences are quoted. Open Archiver's free edition has no licence fee, and its Enterprise Edition is a one-time €14 to €65 per mailbox, depending on how many mailboxes you archive.

Can I import my MailStore archive into Open Archiver?

Not directly. Open Archiver has no MailStore importer, but it imports PST, EML and Mbox files, so mail exported from MailStore in one of those formats can be brought into Open Archiver.

Does Open Archiver have retention policies and legal hold like MailStore?

Only in its paid Enterprise Edition. MailStore Server includes retention policies, legal hold and journaling; Open Archiver's free edition archives, searches and checks each email for changes, and keeps retention, legal hold, the audit trail and journaling for Enterprise.

Does MailStore Server need Windows?

Yes. MailStore Server runs on Windows 11 or Windows Server 2016 to 2025. Open Archiver runs on a Linux server and is used in a web browser.

Sources

Facts checked in November 2026 against these pages. Prices and plans change, so check MailStore’s own pricing page before you decide.